Homes for Sale in Middle Island, NY | Middle Island, NY Real Estate

Middle Island, NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale - 52 Found

Refine Your Search

Sort By: Sort By

Per Page: Per Page

Page: Page

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 … 6 Next

OPEN HOUSES

$675,000

37 Winterberry Drive Middle Island, NY 11953

4 Beds

2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath

Courtesy Of Coldwell Banker M&D Good Life

30 Images Contact

$675,000

37 Winterberry Drive, Middle Island, NY 11953

4 Beds | 2 Full Baths | 1 Half Bath

$675,000

37 Winterberry Drive,
Middle Island, NY 11953
4 Beds | 2 Full Baths | 1 Half Bath

Select previous slideshow image

OPEN HOUSES

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

30 Images

$675K

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/9banrevprd55me6ke23em8b890i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/h3stcc37tvd0mvy63d6d32w1z2i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/yzbcd2y2xnmrmdjyf2bsazzk20i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/gb49wjc2txnh4hyprgdft7s7r7i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/kj86taxc3sz3metw3fc8jehsn7i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/9atqe54jymmy4629sxwznfkmh0i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/zwkzjbpvhe89mxaf73ee9np1t0i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/vbx3908n2tg943yg3g8f7pkk30i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/f30q99b0tnva4gjgqkfr7cr545i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/d8sw1k68kpr74jtcgh48y7pae0i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/609rspj514mrmgy9fgpc9gtvw3i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/p394n98725p64cpp2t93fa9243i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/gre50yrmdk0tmkjrnkhqtv7c73i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/tmgpscds85s6mp66qx9dc004g3i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/1j7n44g3byn2mveqn6y32wzq40i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/5cmt8d24d34hm6ebb53wsypqy3i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/r5bd09vzxjgzm1a90yg58hczj3i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/bw18ge68qyrfmsyhaqn3n07re4i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/7b75j4np8xfgm32p6vcedfy4k7i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/90699t21nz7hmxtkafrdkwkxx1i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/8mfm070vcwm045tafjwkz8s916i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/k5kxkafj5ztcmvp95nwb2dqtw6i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/a73j5gh7wqac4cp1t9h5yxr6j2i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/0dk76wfyetetmpagm3vmh02d12i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/t5a39bv6kf0c486swnbe0kb9d2i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/dntsyzfahcmrmha2q236e7ezp7i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/rqmky34683t6mcp33axynqamm1i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/7d1ndy5d5x04mjt1jed8zadt92i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/0st2zecezs05mwad07cz8req84i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1103i82/bezf8k9ehpb4mgewx7pt4yvaf6i82

NEWLY LISTED

$499,999

33 Saddlebrook Court Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds

2 Full Baths 1 Half Bath

Courtesy Of Signature Premier Properties

4 Images Contact

$499,999

33 Saddlebrook Court, Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds | 2 Full Baths | 1 Half Bath

$499,999

33 Saddlebrook Court,
Middle Island, NY 11953
3 Beds | 2 Full Baths | 1 Half Bath

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

4 Images

$499K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/6f0d13b01f250bbe88f5d55697491aafl-f2677609154r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/6f0d13b01f250bbe88f5d55697491aafl-f1505968550r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/6f0d13b01f250bbe88f5d55697491aafl-f1504782879r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/6f0d13b01f250bbe88f5d55697491aafl-f1010116755r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$259,888

Lot 2 W Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY 11953

Courtesy Of Realty Connect USA LI Inc

1 Image Contact

$259,888

Lot 2 W Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY 11953

$259,888

Lot 2 W Bartlett Road,
Middle Island, NY 11953

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

1 Image

$259K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/1bb5e1f892b5731f02b3d7fbbb8340a0l-f1863863849r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$259,888

Lot 2 W Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY 11953

Courtesy Of Realty Connect USA

1 Image Contact

$259,888

Lot 2 W Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY 11953

$259,888

Lot 2 W Bartlett Road,
Middle Island, NY 11953

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

1 Image

$259K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/b4945f4d7702baea17b59a0b3220f031l-f1863863849r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$749,888

128 W Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY 11953

6 Beds 3,250 Sq. Ft

4 Full Baths

Courtesy Of Realty Connect USA LI Inc

5 Images Contact

$749,888

128 W Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY 11953

6 Beds | 4 Full Baths

$749,888

128 W Bartlett Road,
Middle Island, NY 11953
6 Beds | 4 Full Baths

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

5 Images

$749K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/ca8b6e4f8be87473b59bd1772e32b2ccl-f2059720350r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/ca8b6e4f8be87473b59bd1772e32b2ccl-f1475697434r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/ca8b6e4f8be87473b59bd1772e32b2ccl-f266222946r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/ca8b6e4f8be87473b59bd1772e32b2ccl-f1863863849r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/ca8b6e4f8be87473b59bd1772e32b2ccl-f1998791664r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$749,888

128 W Bartlett Road Middle Island, NY 11953

6 Beds 3,250 Sq. Ft

4 Full Baths

Courtesy Of Realty Connect USA

5 Images Contact

$749,888

128 W Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY 11953

6 Beds | 4 Full Baths

$749,888

128 W Bartlett Road,
Middle Island, NY 11953
6 Beds | 4 Full Baths

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

5 Images

$749K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/878323be11b5a3fcf8f714ec390b2c34l-f2059720350r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/878323be11b5a3fcf8f714ec390b2c34l-f1475697434r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/878323be11b5a3fcf8f714ec390b2c34l-f266222946r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/878323be11b5a3fcf8f714ec390b2c34l-f1863863849r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/878323be11b5a3fcf8f714ec390b2c34l-f1998791664r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$279,000

125 Fairview Circle 125 Middle Island, NY 11953

2 Beds 947 Sq. Ft

1 Full Bath 1 Half Bath

Courtesy Of Signature Premier Properties

14 Images Contact

$279,000

125 Fairview Circle 125, Middle Island, NY 11953

2 Beds | 1 Full Bath | 1 Half Bath

$279,000

125 Fairview Circle 125,
Middle Island, NY 11953
2 Beds | 1 Full Bath | 1 Half Bath

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

14 Images

$279K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f3609189036r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f1098582150r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f2550940792r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f4163663724r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f284261719r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f2165540525r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f3426372146r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f1618395685r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f1600201465r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f2822072564r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f2225922755r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f2709163330r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f2114430855r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/50428d3e4fca133ace6a8a9691d78003l-f153622255r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$549,999

141 Park Lane Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds

2 Full Baths

Courtesy Of Realty Connect USA LI Inc

18 Images Contact

$549,999

141 Park Lane, Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds | 2 Full Baths

$549,999

141 Park Lane,
Middle Island, NY 11953
3 Beds | 2 Full Baths

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

18 Images

$549K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f4090699250r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f2824295391r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f3240780530r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f1656531359r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f3836112356r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f829251582r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f864653554r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f388445081r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f3332981996r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f4255604359r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f3970648736r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f802757344r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f2108310905r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f41172909r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f1086328437r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f996172049r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f762122756r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/338322897750776131418f4d72ae99dbl-f62183964r.jpg

NEWLY LISTED

$549,999

141 Park Lane Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds

2 Full Baths

Courtesy Of Realty Connect USA

26 Images Contact

$549,999

141 Park Lane, Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds | 2 Full Baths

$549,999

141 Park Lane,
Middle Island, NY 11953
3 Beds | 2 Full Baths

Select previous slideshow image

NEWLY LISTED

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

26 Images

$549K

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f4090699250r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f2824295391r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f3240780530r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1656531359r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f3836112356r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f903051566r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f2243307216r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f2138877581r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1390460815r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1139199379r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1318275204r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f3903457870r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1550689126r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f2045763569r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f667093722r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f3136495794r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f955680784r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f3746550996r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f2909737510r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1829776678r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f2702645305r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f578086000r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1167736998r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f4019997301r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f3543779160r.jpg

https://www.century21.com/listhub/thumb/320x240/lh.rdcpix.com/cb990d921422ae71df3f146ccaf5bb66l-f1195724262r.jpg

$589,900

Front Lot Northfield Road Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds

2 Full Baths

Courtesy Of Coldwell Banker American Homes

11 Images Contact

$589,900

Front Lot Northfield Road, Middle Island, NY 11953

3 Beds | 2 Full Baths

$589,900

Front Lot Northfield Road,
Middle Island, NY 11953
3 Beds | 2 Full Baths

Select previous slideshow image

Select next slideshow image

Select Contact regarding property

11 Images

$589K

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/p5mc852476kvm3a3853qj9vt82i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/5yg2m156xgzcmsp4a5hc2ax220i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/w1ctsprrg8x6mbyvd40ze7ng12i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/dysevnj5wkws4vybmzj11n2ha1i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/rjnr01t4b7qg4z2yzmmj5z5vz2i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/v2en7kqg7q5n47y3sdcsxgf3b5i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/0hbd8mttst0xmhydpybqnmsj35i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/p0j4f886f012m42k3h32pxp0v7i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/6ec4ntw87nc34ep6hrfqwc54s5i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/zj2crz7wd0mwmb61yj89s8xfw4i82

https://cb.azureedge.net/1228i82/ygppzv8qjsz94vej70ehjwepa4i82

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 … 6 »